Re-imagining social media as a commemorative space for remembrance and recovery
Presented at INTERACT (International Conference on Human-Computer Interaction) 2021
Our society avoids the topic of death.
There are countless loved ones passing away and we do not make full advantage of digital technology due to the restrained notion.
Commemoration service for social media and a collective mourning system are in grave need.
Digital Traces
Digital volition and social media
We thought about what is the one place we leave a lot of traces consciously or unconsciously on daily basis. Digital presence is deeply stemmed in our life through our social media accounts. But there was a fatal problem that there was no way in reality that people can manage their own accounts after death according to their own will and autonomy in these platforms.
Value Sensitive Design
User research and design
In order to reconcile social media and after death situation with the use of technological interaction. That is, to consider the digital volition, or the general volition of each stakeholder involved in the process, and as a whole it is both resulted as and embraced by a thanatosensitive design to bring the concept of mortality into our daily activity.
A commemorative space for social media
In-depth interview, observation, thematic analysis,
value sensitive design, user testing
User research, UI Design, User Teseting, Qualitative Data Analysis
Soonho Kwon, Minseok Kim, Sunah Hwang, Dongwoo Kim, Younah Kang
What happens to my social media account after I die? How can I manage it when I'm not there anymore?
Observation on processing deaths and mourning behaviors online.
Social media and death
What will happen after I die? We’d probably wonder what’ll happen to my family, friends, my dog or cat that’s left behind.. but hardly about our Instagram account or other social media, maybe because it’s deemed less important, or is something that’s valued less than physical connections. Our identity on social media after demise, is something that’s been explored for many years, and digital traces and presence is one example.
Thanatosensitivity
Digital tombstones and memorials
There has been recent studies on 'thanatosensitivity' that creates and uses technologies that allow us to comprehend, reflect, and discuss the mortality.
iTernal Tombstone
Remote commemoration
Preservation
I-CAN corp., Häkkilä, et al. Interactive Gravestone
Digital memorial
Virtual tombtones
Digital Traces
In an attempt to examine ways to successfully manage the digital traces as well as to provide an online commemoration opportunity, we aimed to sensitively design the commemoration system that considers every stakeholders’ volition, and that can be implemented into everyday life technology.
Digital presence is deeply stemmed in our life through our social media accounts. But there was a fatal problem that there was no way in reality that people can manage their own accounts after death according to their own will and autonomy in these platforms.
Key Problems
Privacy issues
Absence of a manager
Privacy is easily violated, without the owner and unstructured security system and it is aggravated from not having a person to literally manage the account.
In order to reconcile social media and after death situation with the use of technological interaction. That is, to consider the digital volition, or the general volition of EACH stakeholder involved in the process, and as a whole it is both resulted as and embraced by a thanatosensitive design to bring the concept of mortality into our daily activity.
To Extract Values According to
Human Volition and Design
Commemorative Space in Instagram
Dedicated to Remember
and Recover
Research Goals
RQ 1 Investigate user perception on commemoration
RQ 2 Discuss how social media is, and can be utilized as a
commemoration tool
RQ 3 Design social media system for death preparation and
commemoration
RG 4 Evaluate the newly proposed system
Exploratory Research
In-depth Interview
Transcript Coding
Affinity diagraming
Design Requirements
Prototyping and UT
UI Design according to Design Requirements
Pilot UT
User Testing
Evaluation
Final Design Solution
“One can no more look steadily at death than at the sun.”
- Herman Feifel, thantologist
Exploratory Study
Social media and death
With our in-depth interviews, we first approached the users’ thoughts on death, in online situation. Death, involves not only the phase where we’re no longer here, but also the stages right before. However, that is often overlooked and not carefully or intensely touched upon. It’s a subject that is difficult to address, to point at, and is often avoided to talk about. Likewise, it is something that involves so many stakeholders, that in one research it is unfathomable to understand everyone’s needs. However, it was necessary and promising enough to analyze three main stakeholders, who perform separate tasks in very distinct places.
Stakeholders
Three Distinct interviews sessions conducted as exploratory research to identify research questions. Study
targets three types of stakeholders: To-be-deceased, the bereaved, and legacy contact. Interview and
observation participants selected via purposive sampling through requirement survey.
Before Death: how do users want their Instagram be or be managed, after their death?
After Death: how have users commemorated the loss of their close ones or processed their deaths?
Legacy Contact: how was it like to manage the post-mortality of their closed ones?
After Intensive Interviews,
we conducted five hours of affinity diagraming. We extracted five themes and three insights as the key implications for our design solution.
Thematic Analysis
Processing Death
Processing death begins from the moment the person receives the obituary. He or she goes through following emotional stages: a denial, fear, followed by sorrow, then regret.
Purposes and Practices of Commemoration
Essence of purposes and practices of commemoration in fact was both to memorialize the deceased, but also for the sake of the bereaved.
Commemorative Communities
It is born with the common purpose to honor the loved ones, and renew the connections with them, and reaffirm the relationship within the community.
Online Commemoration: Pros and Cons
Some said online platforms certainly lower that barrier and increase accessibility to commemorate and share experiences between the bereaved. Yet, some were doubtful about the sincerity of online commemoration.
Using Social Media After Death
Possibility and potential that social media can entail as an expression tool after someone’s death.
Insights
Role of Writing and Community in Recovery
Two motives of commemoration: Remembrance and Recovery.
Sharing emotional recoverty: Community
Aperiodic Space Detached From Daily Activities
We defined that an aperiodic space is a space separate from daily lives, yet not so faroff that the bereaved finds if difficult to return back to daily life. We suggest that this space could be provided within social media and the profile page of the dead.
Malleable Nature of Account After Death
Social media accounts are representation of oneʼs identity in digital space.
When the owner passes away, it transforms into a space that shares the news, memorialize and is visited by the bereaved. Dissemination, preservation and community.
Design Requirements
A system to to set up commemorative space before death.
1. Setting up the Commemoration Account : All Users
2. Management Account for Account Manager : Legacy Contact
3. Encountering the Commemoration Acount : The Bereaved - followers
To-be-dead
Setting up the Commemoration Account
Legacy Contact
Management Account for Account Manager
Bereaved
Encountering the Commemoration Acount
User Testing
The prototype is largely divided into three distinct sections each focusing on :
A. All Instagram Users
B. Account Manager
C. Commemoration Account Followers
* A. Setting up the Commemoration Account
* B. Managing the account as an Account Manager
* C. Commemorating with the Commemoration Account
→ Six Participants
A. Setting up commemoration account
→ Rare opportunity to delve into the thought of dying
→ Tedious customization process deemed necessary
B. Managing the account as an Account Manager
→ Its role vital to handle emergencies
→ Connecting the deceased with the bereaved
C. Commemorating with the Commemoration Account
→ Community and space to relieve fear and sorrow
→ Thoughtful UI design involving each stakeholderʼs values
Evaluation Summary
Chance to contemplate death
Importance of volition before death
Significance of space for sharing
Publication
Following project was then published at Interact 2021. Bari, Italy.
I had the honor to be the oral presenter at the virutal conference. Full paper can be found here: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-030-85616-8_26
or please find the paper here: